Application and Comparison of Three Temperature and Light Indexes in Simulating Growth and Development of Cucumber in Greenhouse

doi:10． 11755/j． issn． 1006 －7639(2013) －03 －0523

Abstract

Abstract:

From September to December in 2011，the experiments on ＇Jinyou No． 1＇cucumber in different seedtime were conducted in
the greenhouse in Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology． Models of cucumber growth and development in green-
house based on active accumulated temperature (AAT)，effective accumulated temperature (EAT) and thermal effectiveness and pho-
tosynthesis active radiation (TEP) were developed through mensurating meteorological elements and crop data，and the models were
further verified by independent test data． The results show that the root mean squared error (RMSE) based on TEP from seeding stage
to sprouting，blooming，bearing fruits，fruits expanding and autumn stage were 0 d，3 d，4 d，5 d and 4 d，respectively，which were
lower than those simulated by the model based on AAT (1 d，6 d，8 d，11 d and 11 d，respectively) and the model based on EAT
(RMSE is 0 d，4 d，3 d，8 d and 10 d，respectively)． The root mean squared error (RMSE) between the simulated and measured
values of leaf area and plant length based on TEP were 43． 0 cm2and 4． 3 cm，and the determined coefficient (R2) were 0． 98 and 0．
98． The RMSE between the simulated and measured values of leaf area and plant length based on AAT and EAT were 61． 3 cm2and
54． 6 cm2，9． 8 cm and 7． 5 cm． The comparative results show that the simulation precision of growing stage，plant height，leaf area of
greenhouse cucumber based on TEP was obviously higher than that based on AAT and EAT． This study gives the prediction of green-
house cucumber growth index and the growth period，and also supplies a reference to optimizing environment control．

Key words: cucumber, growth and development simulation, AAT, EAT, TEP

摘要：

2011 年 9 ～12 月间，以黄瓜“津优 1 号”(Cucumis sativus linn． cv． Jingyou1)为试材，在南京信息工程大学试验温室进行分批栽培试验，测定温室气象要素和作物数据，分别用活动积温(AAT，Ac-tive accumulated temperature )、有效积温(EAT，Effective accumulated temperature)和辐热积(TEP，Ther-mal effectiveness and photosynthesis active radiation)3 种光温指标模拟温室黄瓜植株叶面积、株高和生育期，并利用独立试验数据对各个模型进行验证。结果表明:用辐热积指标分别模拟黄瓜各生育期(出苗期、开花期、坐果期、果实膨大期、成熟期)距播种日期的天数，其相对标准误差(RMSE)分别为0 d，3 d，4 d，5 d，4 d，小于活动积温法(1 d，6 d，8 d，11 d，11 d)和有效积温法(0 d，4 d，3 d，8 d，10 d)。利用辐热积指标模拟叶面积和株高的相对标准误差(RMSE)分别为 43． 0 cm2和 4． 3 cm，决定系数(R2)分别为 0． 98 和 0． 98，而用活动积温和有效积温指标模拟黄瓜单株叶面积的相对标准误差(RMSE)分别为 61． 3 cm2和 54． 6 cm2，模拟株高的相对标准误差(RMSE)分别为 9． 8 cm 和 7． 5 cm。比较结果显示利用辐热积指标模拟温室黄瓜生育期、株高和叶面积的精度明显高于活动积温和有效积温，该研究为温室黄瓜生长指标和各生育期的预测以及环境调控提供参考。

关键词: 黄瓜, 生长发育模拟, 活动积温, 有效积温, 辐热积

CLC Number:

S162． 5

LI Yemeng，LI Ran，YANG Zaiqiang. Application and Comparison of Three Temperature and Light Indexes in Simulating Growth and Development of Cucumber in Greenhouse [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, DOI: 10． 11755/j． issn． 1006 －7639(2013) －03 －0523.

李叶萌，李　冉，杨再强. 3 种光温指标在模拟设施黄瓜生长发育中的应用与比较 [J]. 干旱气象, DOI: 10． 11755/j． issn． 1006 －7639(2013) －03 －0523.

References

［1］侯锋，李淑菊．我国黄瓜育种研究进展与展望［J］．中国农业科学，2000，33(3):100 －102．

［2］de Wit CT． Photosynthesis of Leaf Canopies［R］． Wageningen，TheNetherlands:PUDOC，1965．

［3］姚桃峰，王润元，王燕．中国小麦生长模拟模型研究概述［J］．干旱气象，2009，27(1):66 －72．

［4］de Wit CT，Brouwer R，Penning de Vries FWT． The simulation ofphotosynthetic systems［A］． Setlik I． Prediction and Management ofPhotosynthetic Productivity［C］． Wageningen，The Netherlands:PU-DOC，1970，47 －70．

［5］de Wit C T． Simulation of assimilation，respiration and transpirationof crops［M］． New York:Wiley，1978．

［6］Jones C A，Kiniry J R，Dyke P． T． CERES － Maize:A SimulationModel of Maize Growth and Development［M］． College Station:Texas A ＆ M University Press，1986．

［7］Ritchie J T，Alocijia E C，Uehara G． IBSNAT/CERES Rice Model［J］． Agrotechnology Transfer，1986，3:1 －5．

［8］Ritchie J R，Otter S． Description and performance of CERES －Wheat: a user － oriented wheat yield model［J］． ARS － UnitedStates Department of Agriculture，Agricultural Research Service，1985，159 －175．

［9］Hoogenboom G，Jones J W，Boote K J． Modeling growth，develop-ment，and yield of grain legumes using SOYGRO，PNUTGRO，andBEANGRO:A review［J］． Trans ASAE，1992，35 (6):2043 －2056．

［10］McCown R L，Hammer G L，Hargreaves J N G，et al． APSIM: anovel software system for model development，model testing andsimulation in agricultural systems research［J］． Agricultural sys-tems，1996，50(3):255 －271．

［11］陈杰．中国温室作物模型研究状况［J］．中国农机化． 2012，(2):29 －32．

［12］李建民．温室厚皮甜瓜幼苗生长模型与生态生理变化规律研究［D］．杨凌:西北农林科技大学，2006．

［13］王会军．温室黄瓜生长发育模拟模型研究［D］．北京:中国农业大学，2004．

［14］李向岭，赵明，李从峰，等．玉米叶面积系数动态特征及其积温模型的建立［J］．作物学报，2011，37(2):321 －330．

［15］李立昆，李玉红，程智慧，等．基于有效积温早春设施厚皮甜瓜果实发育模拟模型［J］．北方园艺，2010(6):97 －100．

［16］李永秀，景元书．温室番茄生长发育模拟模型的验证［J］．浙江农业科学，2007(3):252 －254．

［17］杨再强，罗卫红，陈发棣，等．温室标准切花菊发育模拟与收获期预测模型研究［J］．中国农业科学，2007，40 (6):1229 －1235．

［18］高亮之著．农业模型学基础［M］．香港:天马图书出版社，2004，113 －114．

［19］李永秀，罗卫红，倪纪恒，等．用辐热积法模拟温室黄瓜叶面积、光合速率与干物质产量［J］．农业工程学报，2005，12(21):131－136．

［20］吴兴国，张真和，凌云昕，等．黄瓜周年生产配套技术［M］．北京:中国农业出版社，2000．

［21］尚庆茂，高丽红，王怀松，等．黄瓜无公害生产技术［M］．北京:中国农业出版社，2003．

［22］陶正平，荣明杰，尹凯丹，等．黄瓜产业配套栽培技术［M］．北京:中国农业出版社，2002．

［23］ Goudriaan J，Van Laar H H． Modeling potential crop growthprocesses:textbook with exercises［M］． The Netherlands:KluwerAcademic Publishers，1994．

［24］Li G J，Benoit F，Ceustermans N． Influence of day and night tem-perature on the growth，development and yield of greenhouse sweetpepper［J］． Journal of Zhejiang University，2004，30(5):487 －491．

［25］Turc O，Lecoeur J． Leaf primordium initiation and expanded leafproduction are coordinated through similar response to air tempera-ture in Pea(Pisum sativum L．)［J］． Annals of Botany，1997，80(3): 265 －273．

［26］明村豪，蒋芳玲，王广龙，等．黄瓜壮苗指标与辐热积关系的模拟模型［J］．农业工程学报，2012，28(9):109 －113．

［27］ Marcelis L F M，Heuvelink E，Goudriaan J． Modelling biomassproduction and yield of horticultural crops: a review［J］． ScientiaHorticulturae，1998，74(1):83 －111．

［28］李凤霞，袁海燕，严秀华，等．宁夏灌区水稻不同灌溉量植株高度的气候生态研究［J］．干旱气象，2005，23(3):62 －64．

［29］姚晓红，李侠．气候变暖对天水市川灌地玉米生长发育的影响及对策研究［J］．干旱气象，2006，24(3):57 －61．

［30］费晓玲，丁春兰．甘肃黄土高原地温与冬小麦发育期的关系分析［J］．干旱气象，2009，27(2):148 －151．

[1]	YU Linghua,XIE Wusan,XIONG Shiwei,ZHANG Xintong,XING Cheng,HU Shanshan. Characteristics of Drought and Flood Based on SPEI and Its Impact on Wheat Yield in Chuzhou of Anhui Province [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2021, 39(5): 742-749.
[2]	WENG Zhimei,ZHOU Xuejun,GAN Jingjing,WANG Kai. Rainfall Characteristics of Warm Sector Weathers with Different Patterns in Spring in Zhejiang [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2021, 39(5): 766-774.
[3]	WU Dan,LI Meiqi,GUO Rui,JIA Xiaowei,LIU Hao,LIU Quan. Low-level Wind Shear and Its Weather Situation at Shijiazhuang Zhengding International Airport from 2014 to 2017 [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2021, 39(5): 775-784.
[4]	WU Rongsheng,LI Yunpeng,WU Ruifen,ZHENG Fengjie,SU Yue. Refined Climatic Suitability Division of Sunflower Following Spring Wheat Harvest in Inner Mongolia Based on CLDAS Data [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2021, 39(5): 807-815.
[5]	GAO Hongyan,YANG Yanchao,ZHANG Xi,WANG Dan,CUI Yu,XIE Feng. Forecast Method of Daily Gas Load During Heating Period in Xi’an of Shaanxi Province [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2021, 39(5): 857-863.
[6]	MIN Jingjing,WANG Hua,DONG Yan. Forecast of Natural Gas Consumption in Heating Season Based on EMD and BP Neural Network Methods in Beijing [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2021, 39(5): 864-870.
[7]	WU Huiqin, YANG Linhan, ZHAGN Zhongjie. Analysis on Forecast Effect of Daily Maximum Power Load Variation in Shijiazhuang Based on Three Models [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2021, 39(4): 709-715.
[8]	WU Rongsheng, HOU Qiong, YANG Yuhui, FENG Xuyu, LI Bin, ZHENG Fengjie. Applicability Evaluation of Multi-time-scales Meteorological Drought Indexes in Typical Steppe of Inner Mongolia [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2021, 39(2): 177-184.
[9]	LI Dan, YANG Liping, JIA Chengzhen. Characteristics of Ground Surface Dead Fuel Moisture Content for Different Stand Types in Great Xing’an Mountains and Relevant Affecting Factors#br# #br# #br# #br# [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2021, 39(1): 144-150.
[10]	MA Hao, LIU Changjie, QIAN Qifeng, XU Zheyong, XIAO Jingjing, YANG Ming, GAO Dawei. Analysis on Climatic Characteristics of Extreme High-temperature in Zhejiang Province in May 2018 and Associated Large-scale Circulation [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2020, 38(6): 909-919.
[11]	LI Fangping, MA Shuqing, YANG Ling, ZHEN Xiaoqiong, LV Siwei. Analysis on Echo Evolution of Downburst Based on Array Weather Radar [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2020, 38(6): 947-954.
[12]	HOU Qiong, MIAO Bailing, WANG Yingshun, DONG Chunli. Effects of Water Stress on Soil Moisture in Semiarid Typical Steppe [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2020, 38(6): 987-993.
[13]	ZHANG Xiaopei, FAN Zhichao. Research on Safety Risk Assessment Method of Ground Weather Modification Operation Based on SCA-LEC Model [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2020, 38(6): 1037-1042.
[14]	DONG Fu, ZHANG Ling, ZHANG Haipeng, LI Jia, SONG Liuxian. Review of Ensemble Forecast of Severe Weather Process Based on WRF Model [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2020, 38(5): 699-708.
[15]	NIE Yun, ZHOU Jixian, LI Xijin, RAN Yang, CHEN Chao. Environmental Condition and Structure Feature of a Warm-sector Squall Line Process in Guizhou Province [J]. Journal of Arid Meteorology, 2020, 38(5): 782-793.